Oklahoma Real Estate Seller Charged with Soliciting Murder After $1M Bat Infestation Lawsuit Loss

Oklahoma courthouse where Keith Cathey faces murder solicitation charges after losing million-dollar bat infestation lawsuit

Keith Barton Cathey, a Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, man who lost a major civil case over a bat-infested house he sold to Mike and Sheryl Fritts, was arrested in September 2025 and charged with two counts of solicitation for first-degree murder after authorities alleged that he offered $100,000 to have the couple killed.

The criminal accusations arose after the Frittses won a $526,000 jury verdict in their long-running property dispute with Cathey. According to reporting based on a probable-cause affidavit, an informant recorded conversations in which Cathey allegedly discussed finding someone to kill the couple. Cathey denied that he genuinely intended to arrange a killing and described the episode at the time as a misunderstanding.

The charges were allegations, not findings of guilt. That distinction became especially important later: on May 22, 2026, a Tulsa County jury found Cathey not guilty on both solicitation counts.

How the Dispute Began With a Bat-Infested Home

Mike and Sheryl Fritts bought a Tulsa-area home from Cathey in 2015. Property-sale records reported at the time listed the transaction at $433,500. Soon after moving in, the couple encountered serious problems that ultimately led to the discovery of a large bat infestation inside the structure.

The Frittses said they initially noticed water-related damage affecting several bedrooms and insects they first believed were bedbugs. They later learned the insects were associated with bats and discovered that hundreds of bats had been living within the home's walls and other concealed spaces.

According to accounts of the dispute, remediation required extensive work, including removal of contaminated insulation and drywall, rebuilding portions of the second floor and replacing exterior brickwork. The couple said the cost of addressing the infestation and related damage eventually exceeded what they had paid for the property.

The Civil Case and the $526,000 Verdict

The Frittses pursued Cathey in Tulsa County District Court over the undisclosed condition of the property. The dispute ultimately produced a $526,000 jury verdict in their favor.

Oklahoma's Residential Property Condition Disclosure Act generally requires a seller covered by the law to provide a property-condition disclosure or qualifying disclaimer. The statute defines a defect as a condition that can materially reduce a property's value or impair the health or safety of future occupants, and disclosure obligations are based on a seller's actual knowledge.

In the Fritts case, the jury found that Cathey knowingly conveyed the residence without disclosing an existing bat infestation in violation of the state disclosure law. With attorney fees, costs and other amounts added, reporting in 2025 placed the overall financial exposure connected with the judgment above $1 million.

Cathey challenged the civil judgment on appeal, arguing among other things that the damages were excessive and disputing aspects of the Frittses' remediation evidence. That appeal continued after the criminal case began.

The Alleged $100,000 Murder Solicitation

Cathey's criminal case began after an individual contacted police about conversations concerning the Frittses. According to a probable-cause affidavit described by The Independent, investigators obtained recordings in which Cathey allegedly offered $100,000 for the couple to be killed.

The affidavit also alleged that Cathey said he had unsuccessfully approached other people about carrying out the killings and offered transportation to a potential assailant. Those statements became central to the prosecution's contention that the comments represented an actual solicitation rather than merely angry speech.

Cathey was arrested on September 4, 2025. He was released on $200,000 bond and ordered to have no contact with the Frittses while the criminal case proceeded.

Under Oklahoma law, solicitation for murder in the first degree is a distinct criminal offense. Being charged with the offense, however, did not establish that Cathey possessed the criminal intent required for conviction.

Cathey Said the Comments Were Not a Genuine Murder Plot

When contacted shortly after his arrest, Cathey told The Independent that the situation was a "misunderstanding." His defense later developed that argument more fully at trial, maintaining that the recorded remarks were expressions of anger and frustration over the civil dispute rather than a genuine effort to commission two murders.

The defense challenged the prosecution's interpretation of the conversations and criticized the scope of the police investigation. Cathey testified at trial and maintained that he had been venting rather than seriously trying to arrange violence.

Prosecutors, by contrast, presented the recorded statements and surrounding evidence to the jury as proof of solicitation. The central question was therefore not whether the statements had been made, but whether the state had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that they amounted to the charged crimes.

Later Development: Jury Acquitted Cathey in May 2026

The criminal case reached trial in Tulsa County District Court in May 2026. On May 22, the jury returned not-guilty verdicts on both counts of solicitation for first-degree murder.

The acquittals meant Cathey was not criminally responsible for the alleged solicitation under the charges brought by prosecutors. They did not erase the separate civil verdict concerning the sale of the bat-infested property; the civil and criminal proceedings involved different legal questions, burdens of proof and evidence.

Following the criminal verdict, Cathey's attorneys said the evidence did not demonstrate a genuine plan to have the Frittses killed and criticized investigators for failing to conduct additional interviews that the defense believed would have provided context for the recorded conversation. The Tulsa County District Attorney's Office defended its decision to present the available admissible evidence to a jury and said the verdict was part of the judicial process.

The Civil Judgment Was Later Upheld on Appeal

The property dispute also produced an important later development. On June 26, 2026, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals affirmed the $526,000 judgment against Cathey.

In its disposition in Mike Fritts and Sheryl Fritts v. Keith Cathey, appeal No. 122,873, the court summarized the jury's finding that Cathey knowingly sold the residence without disclosing the existing bat infestation. The appellate court rejected the arguments presented for reversal and left the verdict in place.

The later rulings therefore produced two different outcomes from two different proceedings: Cathey was acquitted of the 2025 criminal solicitation charges, while the Frittses' $526,000 civil verdict over the undisclosed bat infestation remained intact.

Why the Legal Distinction Matters

The case illustrates why civil liability and criminal guilt must be treated separately. The civil jury considered whether Cathey violated his legal obligations in connection with the property sale and whether the Frittses were entitled to damages. The later criminal jury considered whether prosecutors proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Cathey committed solicitation for first-degree murder.

A civil judgment can create substantial financial consequences without establishing criminal liability. Likewise, an arrest or criminal charge describes an accusation by authorities, not a conviction. In Cathey's case, the murder-solicitation accusations ultimately ended in acquittal, while the underlying property judgment survived appellate review.

For Oklahoma homebuyers and sellers, the civil dispute also underscores the importance of the state's property-disclosure requirements. A seller's duty under the Residential Property Condition Disclosure Act turns on the circumstances specified by the statute, including actual knowledge of qualifying defects. Buyers may also use inspections and other due-diligence measures, but an inspection does not automatically eliminate a seller's statutory disclosure obligations.

Read More:

Post a Comment

0 Comments